Why We Care About Lies

A field guide to fibs, fidgets, and the emotional choreography of deception

Lying is far more common than most of us like to admit. Studies suggest the average person tells one to two lies per day, often small “social lies” to avoid conflict or protect feelings. “I love your haircut.” “I’m almost there.” “No, I didn’t eat the last biscuit.” Harmless? Sometimes. But when the stakes are higher, money, relationships, and trust lies can have serious consequences. That’s why spotting deception feels so important.

And yet, research shows even trained professionals (police officers, judges) are only slightly better than chance at detecting lies, with around 54% accuracy. That’s barely better than flipping a coin. So, unless your gut has a PhD in behavioural psychology, you might want to slow down and look for something more reliable than “they blinked too much.”

Popular culture has given us a false sense of confidence. We’re told liars:

• Avoid eye contact
• Fidget constantly
• Stammer or hesitate

But these cues are unreliable. Skilled liars can maintain steady eye contact and appear calm, while honest people under stress may look nervous and be misjudged. This is known as the Othello Error, mistaking the stress of being disbelieved for the stress of lying. Basically, someone sweating through their shirt might just be terrified of being misunderstood, not secretly running a biscuit smuggling ring.

Experts suggest focusing less on single behaviours and more on patterns. Think of it as emotional algebra: does everything add up?

• Words vs. body language: Do their gestures match their words? Someone saying “I’m confident” while shrinking into themselves may be signalling otherwise.
• Microexpressions: Brief, involuntary flashes of emotion, a flicker of fear, anger, or contempt that leaks through before the mask resets. Like emotional Morse code.
• Story detail: Liars often add too much irrelevant detail to sound convincing, or keep things vague to avoid being caught out. “I was at Tesco buying oat milk, not almond, because almond gives me hives, and I saw a pigeon, and…”
• Shifts in baseline: Everyone has a natural way of speaking and moving. Notice sudden changes, such as a higher pitch, longer pauses, or unusual stillness. If someone who normally gesticulates like a weather presenter suddenly freezes, pay attention.

Body language experts highlight some subtle cues that may indicate deception. Think of these as breadcrumbs, not smoking guns:

• Long pauses before answering
• Accelerated blink rate
• A rise in vocal pitch
• Too much eye contact (overcompensating)
• Shrugs, asymmetrical smiles, or defensive arm-folding
• Touching the neck or face, shuffling feet
• Odd stillness freezing to avoid “looking guilty”

These are not guarantees. They’re signals to pay attention, especially if several cluster together. One shrug? Maybe it’s cold. Five shrugs and a sudden interest in their own shoelaces? Hmm.

Culture, personality, and circumstance all shape behaviour. Some people avoid eye contact out of shyness, not deceit. Others fidget when anxious, not dishonest. That’s why lie detection is less about spotting a single “tell” and more about noticing inconsistencies in context. It’s not CSI. It’s emotional pattern recognition.

• Listen more than you watch: Inconsistencies in a story are often more revealing than body language.
• Ask unexpected questions: Liars rehearse. A curveball can expose gaps. “What colour was the wallpaper?”
• Check for over-control: Someone trying too hard to appear calm may be masking. Think emotional Botox.
• Trust your gut, but verify: Intuition can be useful, but always back it with evidence.
• Don’t confront without cause: False accusations can damage trust more than a hidden lie. You don’t want to be the emotional fire alarm that goes off every time someone blinks.

Spotting a liar is less about playing detective and more about paying attention to alignment between words, actions, and context. No single gesture proves deception. But clusters of inconsistencies, especially under pressure, can reveal when someone’s story doesn’t add up.

The truth is that humans are not natural lie detectors. But by slowing down, observing patterns, and resisting the myths, we can sharpen our awareness. The goal isn’t to catch every lie; it’s to build relationships where honesty is the norm, and deception has less room to thrive.

Also: if someone says, “I swear I didn’t eat the last biscuit,” and they’re blinking like Morse code while avoiding eye contact with the empty tin… maybe just let it go. Or bake more biscuits.

Explore more with us:

• Browse Spiralmore collections
• Read our Informal Blog for relaxed insights
• Discover Deconvolution and see what’s happening
• Visit Gwenin for a curated selection of frameworks