When Bad News Travels in a Blazer

A survival guide to truth-telling in systems that flinch, and the art of delivering discomfort with dignity

Let’s begin with the rule itself.
Whispered in staff kitchens.
Inscribed in committee lore.
Passed down like a spell from slightly scorched predecessors:

Or: If you must, at least give them someone else to blame, a solution in hand, and enough distance from the blast radius to protect their blazer.

It’s less of a rule, really.
More of a vibe.
A symptom of something deeper: systems allergic to discomfort and obsessed with optics.

Leaders are not (always) villains.
Often, they are juggling:

• Performance metrics from above
• Budget potholes
• A donor with strong opinions about Medieval Literature
• Five crisis meetings before 10 a.m.
• And fourteen emails that begin with “I hate to escalate this, but…”

Bad news, then, isn’t just content.
It’s a liability. Reputation. Strategic risk.
A leaky roof isn’t just a facilities request; it’s an embarrassment.
A staff grievance isn’t just HR, it’s “How did we not see this coming?”

Which means, structurally:

• Telling the truth can look disloyal
• Naming the rot can sound ungrateful
• Flagging concerns can be treated as a failure to manage at your level

So:

• The truth gets tucked behind jargon
• The risk gets forwarded to another unit
• The fire alarm is replaced with a scented candle and a note that says “monitoring closely”

Rarely directly. Often theatrically.
You might recognise these classics:

• The “Heads Up” Email
  Vague. Hedging. Half-apology, half-exorcism.
• The Strategic Sandwich
  Praise, disaster, “but I know we’ll navigate this brilliantly.”
• The Deferred Honesty Loop
  “Let’s flag this for the next phase.” (There is no next phase.)
• The Intermediary Messenger
  A well-meaning deputy who draws the short straw.
• The Pre-Meeting PDF
  42 pages, six pie charts, and two footnotes of doom… sent at 11:58 p.m.

Because in the world of institutional leadership:
Bad news is tolerated only if it arrives on time, dressed well, and already halfway resolved.

Depends on the listener.
You might get:

• A muted nod + total inaction
• A rapid disavowal: “This wasn’t escalated properly.”
• A deflection: “What’s being done about it now?”
• A crisis mode that focuses more on managing impression than impact
• Or… in rare, shimmering cases… genuine curiosity and follow-through

Those are the unicorn leaders.
Protect them. Nourish them. Tell them the whole truth with context and tea.

Sometimes your message needs subtitles:

• “Morale is low.”
  → Staff retention is at risk.
• “We’re burning out.”
  → Project timelines may be delayed.
• “There’s inequity in the system.”
  → We lack a consistent application of policy review, which may be needed.
• “This student has been harmed.”
  → We may face reputational or legal risk if unaddressed.
• “We need structural change.”
  → Would you like a PowerPoint about phased improvement?

Let’s be honest:
It’s not about lying.
It’s about translation.

Because it encourages:

• Silence
• Delay
• Facade
• Emotional contortion
• Blame games
• Brilliant people second-guessing their own care-based instincts
• A vibe of: Don’t be the problem. Absorb the problem quietly.

And it misses this:
Good leaders don’t want cover-ups.
They want context.
What they need is a culture where bad news isn’t a grenade, but a collaborative reckoning.

Try this approach:

1. Name the issue clearly but calmly.
2. Share the impact on people, systems, or values.
3. Offer 1–2 provisional responses already in motion.
4. Ask: “What else do you need to support a forward path here?”
5. Make it clear: You’re not offloading blame. You’re inviting co-stewardship.

And if you’re scared?
That’s not a sign you’re wrong.
It’s a sign you care more about truth than comfort.

Truth should not be career-limiting.
Compassion should not be politically risky.
And a healthy institution should thank you for noticing the broken pipe, not punish you for pointing it out.

So yes, deliver with care.
But don’t shrink your language to fit someone else’s performance anxiety.
You don’t need to yell.
But you do need to name things.

Because here’s the real rule:
Don’t hide the bad news.
Just carry it with clarity, context, and the courage to stand beside it.

Explore more with us:

• Browse Spiralmore collections
• Read our Informal Blog for relaxed insights
• Discover Deconvolution and see what’s happening
• Visit Gwenin for a curated selection of frameworks